about uscontact

Passing Property values by reference

Author: zemna
Date: April 17, 2021
Share this:

Passing Property values by reference

I was wondering how well properties were integrated into C#.  For example, C# lets you use += with the properties.   It's easy enough to convert:

MyProperty += 4


MyProperty = MyProperty + 4

However, C# won't let you pass a property in as a ref parameter.  For example:

void PassIntByRef(ref int x)


PassIntByRef(ref MyProperty);  <-- this is illegal in C#.

At first I thought C# was being lame. Afterall, why couldn't it do something like:

int __temp = MyProperty;

PassIntByRef(ref __temp); 

MyProperty = __temp;

Then it hit me that was not correct behavior. Consider this example:

int a = 5;

PassPairByRef(ref a, ref a);


void PassPairByRef(ref int x1, ref int x2) {

x1++;         // 1) caller's reference to x1 (variable a) is immediately changed

// since x1 and x2 are the same ref, x2 is changed too!

// 2) So both x1 and x2 are now updated to 6


The naive codegen proposal above obviously would break down here. PassPairByRef  would need some pretty fancy codegen to handle a reference- property. The only way I can imagine is that it would effectively need a pair of delegates to the get_MyProperty  and set_MyProperty methods. That would codegen to something like: delegate int Getter();

delegate void Setter(int val);

void PassPairByRef(Getter x1_get, Setter x1_set, Getter x2_get, Setter x2_set)


x1_set(x1_get() + 1);

} And then the callsite would look something like (this is pseudo-code): PassPairByRef(

new Getter(get_MyProperty), new Setter(set_MyProperty), // ref for x1

new Getter(get_MyProperty), new Setter(set_MyProperty)); // ref for x2

Since this is obviously less efficient than passing normal (non-property) values by-ref, the codegen would probably want two separate versions of the method: one for the normal case and one for properties.

Some random closing thoughts:

1. A higher-level language could certainly do this underneath the covers (and I bet out of the many .NET languages today, there are ones already that do).

2. I think in an alternative universe, the CLR also could have handled this too and allowed languages to directly pass properties as by-ref parameters. The CLR's JITter could handled the codegen above and even managing both versions of the target method; and it could even have an optimized way of indirectly calling get and set property methods.

출처 : http://blogs.msdn.com/jmstall/archive/2006/02/09/property-by-Ref.aspx

Share this:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Professional software development agency estalished in Indonesia. We offers website setup, web application development, fulfillment service, and etc.
Follow us
Follow us to get latest news and tutorials.
2022 - Copyright, All Rights Reserved, Made by ZEMNA.NET with ❤️